Author's Note:
Hello Classmates!
I am rather fond of this piece, particularly the imagery with darkness and the streets. I intended Aly's habitual confusion and wrong turnings about where she is (and her careful counting) to also work to indicate her lost mental state. Did that work?
My areas of concern are fairly varied. I want the title to evoke and add a layer of meaning to the piece, but I'm worried that it's a little surreal and that it isn't adding. I'm a little concerned that the beginning is sort of dull, and conversely that the parts with Eric (especially the mental course of actions when she answers the phone) are a little overwrought. And I'm concerned that the part with the tourist stop seems random, and I'm not sure I'm happy with Aly's thought there-- if it adds anything.
Thank you for any constructive feedback you might have!
Ellen Dowdell
A Real Fishbowl of a World
At night, the streets seemed anxious, twisting unhappily between shadow and thin street lights, which is why she had chosen to venture out in the early afternoon to conduct her business. But she had been unavoidably detained, and visibly hesitated on the steps before setting off briskly, fists in her pockets, coat pulled tight, plunging into the gloaming.
Unfamiliar streets curled around her, and she counted the turnoffs carefully to find her own. Her phone interrupted her at left turn number six, and she fixed the thought in her head as she turned to Becca’s tinny exuberant voice inviting her out to drinks. It was loud where Becca was, full of people.
"Who all is there?" She asked, not really attending to the answer so much as the shadows creeping down the tall buildings.
"Ivan should be here, I think I saw him? Eric, for sure. Come on, Lys, come out and play."
"Mmm," said Alys, still walking. "Eric."
"Yes, Eric. He's nice, Lys, I don't know what you've got against him. And his friends--"
"Why?"
"What?"
"I've told you often enough why I don't like him. I'm not sure why you don't know." Alys' tone was measured and cool. She looked around suddenly, registered her habitual wrong turning, and began to walk in the other direction. She'd only gone a block that time. Something of an improvement.
The voice on the other line could be heard to pout. "You're being selfish, you know, horribly mean and selfish. I haven't seen you in ages, and I call, and ask my absent best mate out for a pint--"
"I'm being selfish? Is that how you see it, Becca?"
Silence, for a while, as that sunk in, but Becca wasn't by her nature the embarrassable sort. "And mean, too," she eventually replied, voice light. "Leaving me here alone with all these strapping men."
"I'm sure you'll fare all right. Somehow."
"Yes, well--"
"Goodnight, Becca." Alys interrupted gently.
Some grumbling, and then: "Goodnight, Lys. Next time."
"Yeah, we'll see."
Alys dropped her phone in her pocket and refocused on her surroundings. The people were still out, moving toward home, or pubs. Not every gargoyle was yet winging to life, not every shadow a murderer, not while she could see these others. And she was closer to home than she remembered walking.
Alys passed a tourist shop, closed for the day, a familiar landmark for her street, and glanced in to reassure herself of the unchanging nature of tourist shops. Masks of Anne Boleyn, of Nelson, of someone once identified to her as Nelson's Mistress-- she had never stopped long enough to read the name. She didn't stop now, either. She believed in earning fame on your own merits, and disliked plaques that read "wife of, mother of." Any fool could marry.
Her phone buzzed again in her pocket, and she pulled it out against the wind long enough to read, "you really are being very selfish," and put it away without answering. It began to buzz again insistently against her hand, a full ringing cycle, a pause, and another call. She sighed, and answered without looking. His voice hit her, and for a moment all of the noise of London whited out. "Alys," he husked, "I've missed you."
She screamed, she hung up, she threw the phone into traffic, she threw herself into traffic. She clenched her hand white around the phone where it cut striations into her palm. She drew breath. She hadn't stopped walking.
He kept talking, content to fill in her silences. "Becca said there was a chance of seeing you tonight, and that you were being stubborn for no good reason. I said I was sure you had a reason, and I hoped it wasn't me. Becca just went off on you for a few minutes. You know how she is." he laughed, inviting her to share a small cruelty.
She remained silent.
He kept on, and his voice filled her head with buzzing. Suddenly it stopped, and she realized he was waiting for a response.
"What?” she said.
"Do they have a concert today?" he repeated, not sounding put out at all.
"Oh. No."
"You know, they should look into working cheaper. We've just picked up a few graduate students for room and board--"
The darkness fell deeply on her own street, which had a dearth of streetlamps. She could almost feel like she was wading through it, splashing puddles of darkness onto her clothes. She reached her front door absolutely soaked through.
"Goodnight Eric." she interrupted, and heard him startle, and his smooth voice tried to recover.
"As soon as I find out what we're doing later I'll give you a call, I know you don't want to be left out of a chance for lamb chop."
"Don’t call me again, Eric. I mean it."
She hung up the phone, and went inside to the warm circles of yellow light against the darkness.
Ellen,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your short story and was challenged by your willingness to explore a paranoid character. Your descriptions of the street and Alys's actions at the beginning set the stage for a roller coaster of confusion and emotion felt by Alys and the reader.
I agree with you that the part concerning Alys's episode while talking on the phone to Eric is a bit confusing. Specifically: "she threw the phone into traffic, she threw herself into traffic. She clenched her hand white around the phone where it cut striations into her palm. She drew breath. She hadn't stopped walking." In this section, I wasn't sure what was actually happening and what was happening inside her head. For some reason, I imagined her literally throwing her phone into traffic and then her body, but then it becomes clear that this did not actually happen. Maybe strive for more clarity here.
Altogether, you portray Alys's character beautifully. You have a unique tone that adds personality to your story, and I look forward to see how to you take it further.
Thank you for sharing,
Marjorie Lupas
Ellen,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading this piece, I love reading largely internal pieces like this where the reader truly gets a sense of the character's mind! Like you said, you imagery and use of darkness is really striking and unique and it gave a lot of life and action to the piece.
I had the same exact feelings as Marjorie about the section where Alys answers the phone and it's Eric, so I won't repeat - but just know I felt the same confusion! I also felt a little too left out when it came to why Alys feels this way about Eric and why she reacts to him the way she does. I'm all for ambiguity, but I think too much is left unknown. Is he simply an ex boyfriend? Did he cheat on her best friend? Did he rape her or something? Or is he just an asshole? It could go in so many different directions, and I think it'd be interesting to pick one and expand!
Really great read!
- Caroline
Ellen,
ReplyDeleteThis is wonderful! I thought you did a good job with the dialogue, and I agree that you did a lovely job with the imagery. I understood Alys pretty well. Like the others, I enjoyed how well you got into her mind. I, for instance, loved the section about the statues and how "any fool could marry." It told us a lot about Alys.
Like Caroline and Marjorie, I did find the long sentence a bit confusing, but I did like how you used the commas. It showed how Alys was confused, frustrated, and frightened. It also made her seem a bit dramatic, which is good if that's what you're going for. I think you need to rearrange the last three sentences in the paragraph or something. That might help.
Also, I think Eric is terribly creepy. If that's what you were going for, you did a good job.
-Haley
Hey Ellen,
ReplyDeleteThis piece was very well done. My favorite part was how you really used a modern setting and a relatable situation. The phone call with Eric had me hooked in and I wanted to know why Alys reacted to him with such distaste. Having your worked framed around a phone call is seems quite original!
As for areas of improvement, I feel there is almost a bit too much chaos with the dialogue. Characters react very swiftly to certain things that are said and as a reader, I need almost a stop sign to slow down with the text. Give a quick background of why Eric did Alys wrong? Why did they break up? Were they engaged?
I am intrigued to see where this ends up.
Thank you for sharing,
Patrick
Yes, you did well on creating a paranoid character, and like the others commented on that one sentence with the commas, it can be quite confusing, but I like it for it show her erratic behavior. Maybe you can find another way to express that behavior more?
ReplyDeleteGood work overall. Your dialogue and descriptions were top-notch.
Cara Eiland
Ellen, I think you are spot on with your darkness imagery and that sense of confusion. You did a great job of letting me feel, with Alys, a genuine disgust and hatred of Eric (regardless of why she feels that way).
ReplyDeleteYou noted that "I'm a little concerned that the beginning is sort of dull, and conversely that the parts with Eric (especially the mental course of actions when she answers the phone) are a little overwrought." I see what you mean here. It's almost as if her conversation with Becca felt too...gentle, calmer than the context would expect. I think you should either try to level out the level of energy from the beginning and ending, or try and highlight a progression. Maybe Lys is just getting more and more frustrated as the night wears on.
I enjoyed the read :)
Scott
Ellen,
ReplyDeleteThis is so compelling to me. I love characters that with mental distresses that can't always be outright explained and understood by everyone. I suspect maybe she had some experience with Eric where he mocked her or her life.
The dialogue feels so natural. I could hear the conversation and picture Becca in a crowded bar being teased by men pulling her from the phone, and Lys being completely annoyed by the attention she's getting, but also not wanting it for herself.
The only confusing part to me was whether she was actually talking to Eric or if it was an internal interaction.
As for the title, I actually started reading by imagining her as a fish in a bowl how she is making turn after turn, sort of roaming and passing things that she's probably seen a million times, so I love the title and it adds another layer of characterization for me.
Great work!
Kate
Ellen,
ReplyDeleteLove this! Alys's emotions are well-evoked and I like the feeling that reality isn't so clear-cut. The tourist-stop is fine, I think, with the idea of something unchanging and stable for a girl who doesn't like change to cling to. Have to say, my favorite part is Alys getting soaked in shadows. That is an amazing image.
Re the title: Surreal is good, but I'm not sure I'm getting the connection between the fishbowl and the story. Though after reading some of the other comments, it makes more sense. I like the freak-out about Eric, but maybe a bit of a hint as to why she reacts that way to him?
Great job!
--Angela
Dear Ellen,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed the dark imagery and sense of confusion you created in this piece. I loved getting to know your character and I feel that you did a great job of revealing her character through both her actions and her conversation with other characters.
I don't think the scene with the tourist booth is to random because it serves to reveal more about Alys and how she appreciated that point of normalcy in her life. I do agree with what some of the others have said about the scene with Eric and the phone. I was confused at first as to whether Alys had actually thrown herself and the phone into the street. I also would love to know more about why Alys despised Eric so much. I definitely think if you wanted, you could expand your story to include an further explanation of their history.
Overall I love your tone and descriptions they really enhanced your story and characters!
Thanks for sharing,
Carson
Ellen,
ReplyDeleteI really liked reading about how Lys was circling around finding her way home. I thought the dialogue broke it up nicely but also showed us how methodical and level Lys is. Like many others have mentioned, I was confused by the "threw herself into traffic" scene a little bit.
I would love to see more about Eric- I immediately assumed that he had taken advantage of her for some reason, or that Lys knew what kind of person he really was. I think it'd be interesting to see you expand on that creepy vibe he gives off, and the tension, and see what you can create!
Thanks,
Jill
Ellen!
ReplyDeleteI really dig the contrasting uses of light and dark. I think it works really well with this piece. In connecting this with her state of being mentally lost, I think that's awesome.
In the phone conversation between Becca and Lys, I think that it seemed very calm and collected. However, with Eric there was a totally different feel. Why did she react this way? I know she's not fond of him, but I suppose I want to know more about the back story there between them. I was also confused about whether or not she was really talking to him or whether she was just really out of it. I think that could be easily fixed though with more solid details!
Your concern over the title is understandable - I get that you want the whole surreal sort of feeling, but I don't quite get the fishbowl thing. Definitely like where you're going with this. I loved the characterization of Becca and Lys. I could get a general feel of their character just through a phone conversation.
Awesome work!
Ellen,
ReplyDeleteYou really did a great job with your descriptions. I absolutely loved the description of darkness: "She could almost feel like she was wading through it, splashing puddles of darkness onto her clothes. She reached her front door absolutely soaked through." Super cool. Good work.
I did get confused a few times as to whether or not it was a phone conversation or a face to face conversation -- especially with Eric. And as Jill said, I was also confused by the "threw herself into traffic" description. I was very concerned for a little bit that she was going to kill herself. Maybe describe more background as to why she is so frustrated with Eric.
Great work!
Allie
Ellen, I really liked how you managed to give us a character who is inside her head (or who seems like someone who would be often) without just giving us what's inside her own head. I am a little confused as to her relation with Eric, and perhaps that needs to be clarified by adding a bit more dialogue between Becca and Alys, but for the most part, you seem to have solid descriptions and word choice. I like where this one could be headed!
ReplyDeleteEllen,
ReplyDeleteI thought you managed to portray darkness through imagery. I'm very interested in Alys and Eric's past. Maybe you should include more of their story? Also I was a tad confused with the line "she threw her phone into traffic..." maybe I missed something? I just didn't catch the meaning or did she literally throw herself in traffic? Either way, I would really like to know what's going on with Eric and Alys.
Thanks for sharing!
Melissa