The following is my creative response. If it looks familiar, it's because you heard me share it in class. I've never taken a creative writing course before, so I'm proud of the piece, if for no other reason than creating something outside my comfort zone.
I like that my dialogue is quick and fast-paced. I think this makes it more believable. Since the scene is simply two characters moving through a market, it would feel out of place to insert some monologue or soliloquy into the dialogue. However, I think having such short snippets of dialogue also keeps me from having that "dual function" in my dialogue. I'd love some suggestions there.
My other question is about the final sentence. Perhaps I just feel like I want whatever I want to have a clear "moral of the story," but I like the closing sentence. However, Professor Acevedo had some questions about what brought Paul to this conclusion. I would love feedback here. Maybe there's a way to get across the same idea (we should be giving more unexpected gifts these days! :) ) without being so overtly explicit. I just didn't want my story to feel...pointless. If that makes sense.
Well, happy reading, and on with the show!
More
Tulips
All he needed was
to grab some fresh flowers on his way home. A recompense for the inevitable. If
not already, Rhonda would soon notice the china cabinet was one dessert plate
short of a full set. Then Paul would have to fess up, and there was no way to
spin the story to a positive light. No clever propaganda or cheery tone could
change the fact that there was broken china in the waste bin.
Snapping back to
the present, Paul looked down the first corridor flanked by small stalls, each
with a green and white plastic awning. He’d been through this market countless
times before, but each time he stepped into the cramped maze he found himself
bewildered. He stopped for a minute in the middle of the aisle, trying to recall
his surroundings.
“Watch it,
mister!” a young lady had run into him from behind.
“Sorry, just
trying to find some flowers,” Paul replied.
“Don’t stand
here—stand there!” The lady tapped her foot and pointed to one side of the
passage. She wore a faded red t-shirt, high-waisted jean shorts, striped
leggings, and well-worn hiking boots. She couldn’t have been more than 25. She
stared at Paul for a moment, eyebrow raised. “Well, clearly you aren’t gonna
find flowers anytime soon without some help. You’re as clueless a shopper as my
dad.”
Paul just stood
there, unsure of how to react.
“Hi, I’m Jen.” She
grabbed Paul’s hand from its place at his side and shook it vigorously. She
didn’t wait for a response. “Follow me,” she said and started walking down the
aisle.
“What do you need
flowers for?” Jen asked.
Paul realized how
long it had been since he’d contributed to the conversation. “It’s a long
story,” he said.
“Let me guess. You
did something to upset your wife, and you’re bringing home flowers to lessen
her anger.” She spoke matter-of-factly, as she deftly maneuvered through the
market, taking a left and another quick right.
Paul gaped. “How
did you know?”
“There’s only two
reasons people buy flowers these days: funerals and apologies. And you aren’t wearing
black.”
Paul was struck at
the insight from such a young person. Jen couldn’t have been more than
twenty-five. “You know, Jen?” He thought aloud. “It didn’t use to be that way.
People used to bring home flowers not just for special occasions, but just
because.”
“Ain’t that
sweet,” Jen said with an air of indifference. She cared more about her striped
leggings than she did some absurd nostalgia. “Well, here’s the flower shop,
Paul.” She pointed ahead to the stall. Silver buckets lined the counter, tilted
forward, filled with a garden of lilies and tulips. “See you around.” She left
before Paul could even raise a hand and wave.
Paul bought a
small bouquet of yellow tulips, six pounds, and headed toward the flat, toward
apologies and disappointment, resolved not to break less china, but to buy more
tulips.
Scott,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed hearing your story in class for the first time and have an even greater appreciation for it after reading it myself. Your images are clear, and you brought both of your characters to life through action throughout the piece. I particularly enjoyed reading the description of Jen. You can tell just by looking at her that she's young, confident, and British.
There's two parts of the story where you say that Jen could not be older than 25. I think that only needs to be said once, but that's a minor correction.
I appreciate the roundness of your story and that you address the broken china at the beginning and the end. However, I agree with Professor Acevedo and would encourage you to consider another way to develop Paul as a character. Perhaps reveal a little more of his feelings toward Wanda or the situation through action. Is he buying flowers out of duty, or he is determined now to buy them "just because" he loves Rhonda as his wife? It might turn into a longer piece if you do this, but I think it's worth considering.
All in all, well done. I think that your message is clear and applicable. I like that you want purpose for your writing, and it shows in this piece.
Thanks for sharing,
Marjorie Lupas
Pop-Pop,
ReplyDeleteThis is a fun little piece and you've done a great job highlighting setting and character details! I like that Paul's realization was simple and sweet rather than anything too heavy or life altering, because not all realizations worth writing about are so serious as all that! I'm glad the tulips didn't remind Paul of his dead dog or something.
I agree that your dialogue is natural and believable, but I think it could use a little bit more believable initiation into conversation, right now it feels a little sudden to me. Maybe after Jen tells him to move over, Paul asks her if a girl would like carnations (no girl wants to be given carnations) and then Jen sees his hopelessness and thus offers her assistance? This is just a suggestion, but I think something like this would provide a better catalyst for their extended interaction!
Great job!
- Caroline
I agree that you have done a good job at bringing your characters alive. We know that you have experienced something similar to this, so it comes out in your writing.
ReplyDeleteLike the other two who have responded, it would be good to get more from your character Paul. He needs to reveal his thoughts. Right now he is just so shocked at what is happening around him, which is quite comical.
Keep up the good work!
Scott,
ReplyDeleteThis is such a great scene! I can see so many guys doing something like this, which is what makes it so fun to me. I feel like I have a pretty clear idea of Paul. He doesn't seem like a bad guy at all. He just seems to have lost the whole "just because" gift-giving that might have happened earlier in their relationship. You could always hint somewhere that he used to give more gifts or have more surprises for his wife (if that's true).
I do wonder if you could say something other than "snapping back to the present" to show the change from his thoughts to what is currently happening.
I don't mind the way they meet, but I think Caroline's idea could work well. She's right about carnations. That was middle school. Something you might want to ask yourself: Is Paul the type of person who would know his wife's favorite flowers?
I liked your message, and I felt like your scene did a good job of showing it.
Great job!
-Haley
Hey Scott,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed seeing this piece again. I could really identify and or say I know plenty of men who have been in Paul's shoes. You do a quality job of painting his remorse and his wanting to genuinely smooth things over with his better half. It is also comforting to see your use of setting, this seems to be set in a store back in the Southern America.
Things you could improve on, I would suggest maybe having Paul impart some of his wisdom on Jen. Jen seems to be calling the shots and really teaching Paul a valuable moral lesson. However, she is obviously a lot younger than Paul. Maybe make Paul stronger in his convictions and have him tell Jen about something he did right. Maybe then, they can both teach each other a lesson, and both be better off for it.
This was a strong piece Scott! Keep up the great work,
Patrick
Scott,
ReplyDeleteI agree with you about your dialogue: it does feel natural. The whole story feels natural, like it can and does happen to people anytime. Not all realizations are serious and dark and sad, and thanks for that reminder.
Perhaps, if you want to keep the last line, which I like, introduce the idea of "just because" flowers earlier, or add a bit more conversation between Paul and Jen after she says "Ain't that sweet". You don't have to add a soliloquy--perhaps just a line of introspection here or there.
Looking forward to seeing how it turns out!
--Angela
Scott,
ReplyDeleteI enjoy your no-nonsense syntax (for lack of a better term). Each sentence is to the point and says just enough, so good work!
I'd like to get an idea of how old Paul is. Is he young, middle-aged, old? For me, that would add more depth to his character and help me make assumptions about whether he's had to buy flowers before or is this a first.
I'd also like to maybe know why is she helping him? Is she board; does she think he's cute; is she just being nice?
You also say she is 25 twice ;)
The ending is perfect to me. It is a perfect little poetic tidbit.
Kate
Scott,
ReplyDeleteYour first paragraph is an excellent hook, and your prose stays very close to your characters thoughts in a homey, easy way. I love the point of view of the older man presented, and the mild touches of humor that interweave. I am also a large fan of the ending-- I don't think it comes off too moralistic, but as this vow, this gesture, to love more, and it's sweet.
This is a nitpicky thing: I don't like the line about being "preoccupied with her tights"-- as a "she cares more about x" it's fairly weak, possibly from its unorthodoxy, and she's already proved to be perceptive about the flowers and human nature, so it rings a littel false. I think you could still carry a "oh the younger generation" vibe with a different comparison.
I want to agree with the person above that you don't necessarily need to add more dialogue, but can just give a little introspection to significant lines to add depth to them.
It's a very hopeful piece, and I really like that. This story works for me.
-Ellen
Dear Scott,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed seeing your piece again. I like that you choose a scene that seems so common and made it come to life. Your dialogue really helps to move your place along and make it realistic.
If you wanted to add more of the moral of your story and show how Paul came to this conclusion, then perhaps you could add a small bit of Paul's inner musing after Jen leaves him at the flowers. Maybe show his personal reaction to her easy dismissal of his remark about how small gifts used to be more frequent. Just a thought.
Overall, I really enjoyed reading a story with a happy and uplifting moral!
Thanks for sharing,
Carson
Scott,
ReplyDeleteYour piece was such a fun, light read for me. I really like how you illustrated Paul's mission and thought process, and the other characters at well. I felt like I was comparing them to people I know in real life.
I thought it was interesting that Patrick commented that Paul is obviously much older than Jen. I am not sure that I got the sense that he is much older, although obviously married, so maybe you could work on that to show the differences between the generations, and add that in with the motif of random gift giving.
Really great job! thanks for sharing twice :)
Jill
Pop-Pop/Scott,
ReplyDeleteNice job! I really enjoyed it and I think the pacing of the dialogue is spot on with the pacing of the story - quick and to the point. I definitely liked that. It was easy to follow, you characterized Jen well. On that same note, I feel that Paul is a little lacking and possibly overshadowed. I agree with Caroline's statement about the conversation seeming sudden. However, Jen is definitely an extrovert. So, perhaps it's really not that unlikely she would be so apt to confront him.
I would like to know more about how Paul broke the plate. I think that it would add a bit of humor to the story. It could show him freaking out and panicking. Who doesn't like to see a clueless man wig out every now and again? Your story is so light-hearted and sweet that I don't think that it would detract from the tone at all. Just give it a shot, if nothing else.
Awesome job!
Morgan
Scott,
ReplyDeleteI loved both hearing this piece in class and reading it again on here. I think it is so true about people never buying flowers just because anymore and you did a great job at showing Jen's frustration with this throughout the story. The dialogue is very natural and easy to read. As for the end, I really liked it. I thought it was a great execution of "retuning the characters to life." If you wanted to make the story more dramatic, maybe you could change the flower buying incident to something more intense to further prove your point of flowers only being purchased for saying sorry or for funerals.
Great work!
Allie
Scott, I found this story pretty delightful, and pretty British (maybe that's just me, but maybe you've already been able to absorb your environment in a convincing way). I really like the line “There’s only two reasons people buy flowers these days: funerals and apologies. And you aren’t wearing black.” And I think the whole thing has an easy-going tone to it. I think the question Haley asked you to think about goes a long way to helping you figure out more about Paul, which is exactly what you leave the reader wanting. Keep up the good work!
ReplyDeleteScott,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed this piece when you read it in class and I got to enjoy it again. I really love the dialogue. It fits so well! I also really loved the light and happy tone I got from this.
You're story is well rounded and I thought it ended really well. I really love Jen and Paul's personalities. You can tell they are completely opposite. I would personally like to know about Jen. Why are flowers usually bought for funerals and apologies?
Thanks for sharing!
Melissa